| Muslims in Canada, the UK and the US?

Muslims in Canada, the UK and the US?

*ajidamoon* the Eh team asked:


I was just glancing through a couple of pages of questions on here, and came across one about the Pledge of Allegiance in the US.

This got me to thinking about something that is going on in Canada right now. A school in the Maritimes, has decided to cancel the playing of the National Anthem, O’ Canada, at the beginning of opening exercises each morning. Now the school is trying to keep the reasoning hush hush, hinting toward a couple parents who complained about their children having to listen. And there is also speculation that the Principal, who ran for the Green Party in the last election, has political motives having to do with the War in the Middle East….
After hearing that on the news, that got me to thinking about high school, which was round abouts a decade ago for me. The high school I went to had an excellent English As a Second Language program, and we would get the students who were recent immigrants, or on exchange from various countries. That meant many Muslims, from differing countries, Serbians, Hungarians, Russians, Argentinians, Indians, Saudi Arabians………tons, from all over the world. I noticed that the Muslim girls would step out of the classroom, into the hallway, during the National Anthem. Why is this?
As a teen, I didn’t think about it much. Having my own “terrible high school problems” I didn’t really devote much time to thinking about the wonderful country I was lucky enough to have my ancestors live in for the last several thousand years. Now though, thinking about it, I’m a bit upset. Is there a religious reason they would treat my country with such disrespect? If you come here seeking a better or new life, isn’t some respect due? Or is it merely a cultural thing? Would it have had to do with their home country rather than religion?
Am I wrong to be offended and upset? Canada is a multicultural, diverse country, yes. That is one thing I love. But seeing as how being a Canadian is the only common thing that unites us all, shouldn,t we show this country respect by listening to the National Anthem, proud that we can be a part of something trying to create some good in this world? Same goes for the UK, or whatever country you may happen to be living in.
Thoughts?
Yes, I know it is long and rambling. But the question is in there, I promise. Last paragraph, I believe.
Yes, we dropped the Pledge back when I was in grade school. And we are not required to sing the National Anthem at school, just listen to it play over the PA system. Sometimes the English/French version, most of the time just the instrumental.
This is the first time I have ever heard of a school dropping the Anthem. And right on the heels of all that rubbish to do with the 2010 Olympics too.

Related posts:

  1. Mess up on Korean E2 Foreign Language Teaching Visa requirements? haphazard.moogle asked: I’m looking at getting a job at a...
  2. No plagiarism-I don’t know how to credit a play I saw at school? Beep B asked: I need help writing a reference for:...
  3. learning languages in school? b_kelly95 asked: what language do you learn in school? im...

Filed Under Ramadan |

Tagged With , ,

Comments

6 Responses to “Muslims in Canada, the UK and the US?”

  1. ‪ on June 6th, 2009 12:06 pm

    Well, I don’t find what’s wrong with it. Canada has done so much for all of us, and we should respect it no matter what. I don’t understand why that principal would stop the national anthem…

    I mean troops from Canada have been sent to Afghanistan, and fought for Afghanistan’s sake, and they got killed. I mean they worked incredibly hard to make Afghans feel safe. We should respect them, so I don’t think anyone has rights to cancel the national anthem.

    EDIT: No, here in middle schools and high schools, we just listen. In elementary schools, we sing. But still, I still believe we should listen to National Anthem because look at the things Canada has done for us to live safely.

  2. those crazy muzzies on June 7th, 2009 10:55 pm

    because they are ungreatfull beings that do not deserve to be in Canada.

  3. biro206 on June 9th, 2009 2:00 am

    whats wrong with a national anthem…..

  4. iantendo on June 10th, 2009 2:29 pm

    to be honest in the UK we don’t do anything like having to sing the national anthem or pledge alledgience to the flag or anything like that, so the issue never really came up.

    We did used to pray in assembly sometime though, but the non-Christian kids would never leave the room they would participate as well.

  5. [ Triɳket forever ] on June 13th, 2009 3:07 pm

    Well The pledge of Allegiance is not OK with Islam because your Allegiance lies with Allah and Allah alone.
    However I do not understand what is wrong with listening to the National Anthem of any country…I mean even Saudi has a national Anthem.. And Pakistan and Iraq and Yemen… etc

    *Sings O Canada*

  6. gen patton on June 14th, 2009 11:24 am

    well, let me add my penny here. maybe all those nice people didn’t come here (or to your country) to have a better life and become canadians. maybe they came to change your country into one of theirs. the first thing they do is, complain how we are trying to change them, while changing our country. the time is long past due for people to take their countries back, and not worry about hurting anybodies feelings. and get our a$$es out of their country and let them kill each other. if they don’t want to fight for their own country why let them change ours.